Single vote breaks rules for site plan
Published at 16:39, Thursday, 13 September 2012
AN angry homeowner has hit out at Lake District bosses for breaking their own policies to allow a major planning application to go ahead.
Former paramedic Ron Dickson fought proposals to build a new car showroom on a green field site just metres from his home in Lindale.
But the plans, for a new Toyota dealership and workshop at the existing Bateman BMW and Mini, were passed by one vote at the authority’s development control meeting in April.
Now Mr Dickson, who retired to his bungalow with his disabled wife Noelle in 1996, claims he has received no acknowledgements to his letters querying the decision.
The father of one added he has been told his only right of appeal is to take the case to judicial review – a complex legal process costing tens of thousands of pounds.
“All I’ve got is my home and they’ve ruined that with this decision,” Mr Dickson said.
“So how am I supposed to afford to get a second opinion on whether this development should actually be allowed to go ahead?
“I’ve lost faith in the national park authority. It’s totally weighted against individual residents and their rights.”
Members of the authority’s development control committee were told the proposals went against existing planning policy when the matter was discussed five months ago.
But it succeeded by one vote on the basis that 21 jobs at the firm would be saved.
The committee was also told that a further 13 jobs could be created over five years if planning permission was given a green light.
In a letter explaining the case to Westmorland and Lonsdale MP Tim Farron, LDNPA chief executive, Richard Leafe, claimed the application was seen as an exception to planning policy because it safeguarded 40 jobs.
Mr Dickson added: “Where did this figure come from? It’s seems to be a fabrication to justify the fact that they’ve bent their own rules to allow this application through.
“The whole thing stinks and I feel terribly let down by the system.”
LDNPA planning officer Ben Long responded to the claims, stating the Bateman Toyota application had been a finely balanced case.
He added that Mr Leafe had been talking in “higher terms” within the letter to Mr Farron and that the figure of 40 jobs had been “an approximation”.
“It was a real balancing act which on this occasion amounted to significant economic benefits against limited harm to the land,” Mr Long said.
“Economic prosperity within the national park is a key planning consideration and the committee felt it warranted a departure from planning policy for this application.”
Mr Dickson was refused planning permission for a caravan park on the land in question in 2000.
And the Bateman Toyota application was itself first rejected by national park planners in 2009.
Mr Farron, who has repeatedly called for national park representatives to be publicly elected, said he hoped a mutually agreeable solution could soon be found.
“I would hope that a representative from the national park will meet with Mr Dickson to listen to his concerns and help find a way forward,” he said.
Published by http://www.nwemail.co.uk
More Grange news
- Officials take advice on range of ideas for Grange historic lido
- SLIDESHOW: Cartmel family race proves a winning formula
- South Cumbria school praised for helping children feel right at home
- SLIDESHOW: Sun shines on Cartmel racegoers as bank holiday meeting starts
- Grange woman who fraudulently claimed benefits in court (2 comments)
- Barrow, South Lakes and Copeland voters share their views
- Puddles the Cumbria otter cub travels to specialist hospital in Scotland
- Good Samaritan tells of impact of Grange drunk’s attack
- South Lakes housing estate plan approved
- Store owner appeals to public after £25,000 jewellery heist
- Grange man accused of grooming girl for sex
- Loved ones remembered at Cumbria service
- New Grange estate proposal branded ‘vandalism of a public view’
- Cumbria sex offender pensioner due in court today charged with loitering near children's play area
- Cumbria fly-tipper admits dumping his old sofa
- High winds close outdoor exhibition in South Cumbria
- Cartmel Races - Betfair Barbecue Day 2014
- Cartmel Races - Totepool Cumbria Crystal Hurdle Day 2014
- Two race horses perish at Cartmel races in South Cumbria (16 comments)
- Consultation begins on £1.4m South Cumbria homes proposal (1 comment)
- Cartmel Vintage Race Night
- Barrow bakery has recipe for success
- Car stolen in South Cumbria
- Barrow and Grange venues for summer street gallery exhibition
- Cumbria chef Simon Rogan wins another accolade
Evening Mail homepage
ENERGY FOR LIFE 5.1k WALNEY FAMILY FUN RUN
Did you enjoy the Energy For Life 5.1k Walney Family Fun Run?
• Click here to pledge to take part in next year's event on September 2, 2012
- Barrow's Hairy Biker married
- Era of food shortages made worse by blizzard
- Barrow rooftop stand off man to appear in court
- United Utilities apprentices on top of customer service
- Barrow pitbull owner in bid to save dog on death row (29 comments)
- Chinese translation company opens Lake District base
- Kids enjoy All Saints Day
- Jobs threat at nuclear agency in Cumbria (3 comments)
- Black Combe Runners' Paula produces solid run
- Cartmel Races - Betfair Barbecue Day 2014
F. Dickinson footwear
Homes and gardens 22