In the icy footsteps of South Pole pioneer
Last updated at 10:27, Wednesday, 03 November 2010
FEW people have had the opportunity to experience the many hardships faced by pioneering Antarctic explorers than Geoff Somers who came to Grange Lecture Society to contrast some of his adventures with those of Captain Robert Scott.
As most school boys used to know, Scott was one of the British Empire’s heroic failures whose team lost out on being first to the South Pole but then redeemed themselves in the brave manner of their long but unsuccessful battle for survival against the worst that nature could throw against them.
Mr Somers chose the controversial title of Scott, Hero or Loser? for his illustrated talk to around 200 people at the Victoria Hall for the Nevile Burwell Memorial Lecture, but left his audience in little doubt that he was a Scott fan.
The MBE and Polar Medal holder led an expedition to the South Pole five years ago with a group of four city workers “who wanted to do something different.”
They certainly got what they asked for – kitted out in retro clothing of the type which Scott used almost 100 years earlier.
At the end of the talk there was an opportunity to examine expedition items including a reindeer sleeping bag, wooden skis, bamboo ski poles and beaver fur gloves.
The expedition sledges were made in Gloucester and could carry enough to keep the team alive for up to 30 days in the snow and ice.
They even persuaded McVitie’s to make up a batch of biscuits to a 1910 recipe.
He said: “We had to have everything specially made for us.”
The modern trip had a few corners shaved. Flights and a 200-mile trek compared to Scott’s hazardous sea journey taking three months before the walking started.
Another important difference was the chance to quit or call for help, which was never available to Scott or his fellow pioneers.
He said: “Today’s travellers survive because of two very import things – radio telephone and aeroplanes.
“Scott had no way of being rescued. It is impossible today to do an expedition when you are totally on your own.” Training for the modern expedition included running up Lakeland fells pulling car tyres on a rope to replicate the effort of hauling a sledge across ice.
The South Pole had proved to be a tough nut to crack for explorers.
Shackleton got to within 100 miles in 1907 while Scott got there in 1912 only to be deflated by news that the Norwegians had been there first.Scott’s diary entry for January 18 in 1912 noted: “Great God, this is a terrible place.”
He was still 800 miles from help and running out of food but still got to within 11 miles of safety.
Mr Somers said: “He didn’t blame anyone but himself.”
Compare that with today’s South Pole where there is a permanent research base which has a music room, library, pool room and laundrette.
While Scott’s team melted snow to drink, today’s scientists can enjoy beef burgers or fish and chips.
l The next event at Grange Lecture Society in on November 9 when Mark Baldwin will talk about The Battle of the Atlantic and the role of U-boats. The talk starts at 7.15pm in the Victoria Hall, Grange.
First published at 10:15, Wednesday, 03 November 2010
Published by http://www.nwemail.co.uk
More Grange news
- Officials take advice on range of ideas for Grange historic lido
- SLIDESHOW: Cartmel family race proves a winning formula
- South Cumbria school praised for helping children feel right at home
- SLIDESHOW: Sun shines on Cartmel racegoers as bank holiday meeting starts
- Grange woman who fraudulently claimed benefits in court (2 comments)
- Barrow, South Lakes and Copeland voters share their views
- Puddles the Cumbria otter cub travels to specialist hospital in Scotland
- Good Samaritan tells of impact of Grange drunk’s attack
- South Lakes housing estate plan approved
- Store owner appeals to public after £25,000 jewellery heist
- Grange man accused of grooming girl for sex
- Loved ones remembered at Cumbria service
- New Grange estate proposal branded ‘vandalism of a public view’
- Cumbria sex offender pensioner due in court today charged with loitering near children's play area
- Cumbria fly-tipper admits dumping his old sofa
- High winds close outdoor exhibition in South Cumbria
- Cartmel Races - Betfair Barbecue Day 2014
- Cartmel Races - Totepool Cumbria Crystal Hurdle Day 2014
- Two race horses perish at Cartmel races in South Cumbria (16 comments)
- Consultation begins on £1.4m South Cumbria homes proposal (1 comment)
- Cartmel Vintage Race Night
- Barrow bakery has recipe for success
- Car stolen in South Cumbria
- Barrow and Grange venues for summer street gallery exhibition
- Cumbria chef Simon Rogan wins another accolade
Evening Mail homepage
ENERGY FOR LIFE 5.1k WALNEY FAMILY FUN RUN
Did you enjoy the Energy For Life 5.1k Walney Family Fun Run?
• Click here to pledge to take part in next year's event on September 2, 2012
- Barrow man accused of having a sword in public
- Barrow man jailed after benefits mix up left him without food (7 comments)
- Correct result
- Flashback: Theatre Groups
- Furness Academy firm on its uniform rules
- Hotel to blame for food poisoning
- Valuable information for your holiday plans
- Great days at town’s lost shops and pubs
- Maryport colleagues run for cancer charity
- Loco built for Barrow shipyard enjoys retirement in Oz
F. Dickinson footwear
Homes and gardens 22